Here at the Strategist UK, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing ones. (You can learn more about our rating system and how we pick each item here.)
While we’ve written about all kinds of essentials before — including the best coffee makers, the best pens, and the best chef’s knives — here, we’ve rounded up the best dog halloween costumes, as praised by the most enthusiastic reviewers on Amazon.co.uk.
Best-rated overall dog Halloween costume
In total, 73 percent of reviewers gave this costume five stars. The costume comes in sizes ranging from S-XL, though the fit will depend entirely on the dog breed. One customer said the XL fit their small Dalmatian perfectly (others said this size was best for “tall, skinny” dogs such as lurchers or Patterdale terriers). The large fit a young Labradoodle well, while the medium was deemed perfect for a pug. According to one reviewer who bought the costume for their terrier ahead of a sci-fi film festival in London, the fabric and the fit were comfortable on their dog, and it was easy to put on (they even ended up winning a prize for best-dressed). Another customer who bought it in small for their King Charles Spaniel said it made trick-or-treating with his young nephew particularly entertaining.
And now for some micro-picks for every type of dog Halloween costume you might be looking for
Best Freddie Kruger costume
This Nightmare on Elm Street costume has 75 percent five-star reviews, and also comes in sizes S-XL. It consists of a hat, sweatshirt, and claw, and uses velcro to attach under the stomach, which hides the seams, according to one customer. It also came recommended by the owner of a Jack Russell mix who said that while it was a lot to pay for an outfit, it was money well spent. One customer said the claw attachment came off easily (not helped by her dog being fond of chewing) but that the overall outfit went down well at her dog’s day-care Halloween party. Similarly, the slashes in the jumper may be bothersome to some dogs — one of the few unhappy customers said her pup simply ripped this up while wearing it.
Best Superman dog costume
This Superman costume, which includes a cap, front bib, and utility belt, has 73 percent five-star reviews. Customers said the sizing was straightforward, with most people correctly guessing their dog’s size (for example, XL fits a husky, and large fits a Border collie). The owner of a beagle said that despite the different parts, it was easy to attach, and didn’t come loose or bother his dog (in fact they went to a carnival together and he didn’t try to take it off once). Another said their dog got lots of compliments when they wore it out.
Best Jedi Costume
Seventy-three percent of reviews for this Star Wars Jedi outfit are five stars. Rubie’s says the small size would suit breeds including Chihuahuas, Pomeranians, Australian terriers, Yorkshire terriers, and toy poodles (but it also provides a size chart depending on breed). Thirty-five customers said they loved this costume, with many saying the looser design made it easy to put on their dogs (even if several didn’t enjoy having the hood up). The medium size caused some problems with the small ear holes, according to the owner of a cocker spaniel, but breeds with smaller ears seemed to fit in them just fine. Twenty-three reviewers said it was the most adorable outfit they’d bought their pet.
Best Ewok costume
According to one Star Wars fan, this outfit was the perfect purchase for their May the Fourth celebrations. Their schnauzer wore a medium, which they said was perfect — although another customer said their Shih Tzu, Dougie, couldn’t fit in a medium (they conceded their dog was “big for his breed”). Over 100 reviews — or one in five — said this was the “cutest” outfit for their dog. The drawstring on the hood tightens for a better fit, which suited one owner, who said their dog often shook their head to try and dislodge it.
Best Batman costume
In total, 60 percent of reviewers gave this outfit five stars. Twenty-three reviewers said this outfit was “perfect” for their dog — happy customers included a six-year-old Shiba Inu, a German shepherd, and a golden retriever. A number of reviewers also said that it was easy to put on their pet — including the owner of a schnauzer, who said it was hard finding an outfit that fit his chest and waist equally well. The costume uses drawstrings so even if the outfit comes up a little small — as was the case with one Great Dane, who was too big even for the XL size — it can be loosened to fit. This also meant it was great for growing puppies — one reviewer bought this when their husky was still growing and says it’s easy to adjust each year.
Best Robin costume
In total, 116 reviewers said this outfit was particularly cute on their pet, and 46 said their dog “loved” wearing it. One cat owner even said the smallest size fit his feline almost perfectly (citing the long sleeves as the only problem). Among dog owners, 32 said they thought the costume fit well, including the owner of a Boston terrier who advised to buy a size up — saying that the velcro fastening makes it easier to make a larger costume fit neater.
Best formal costume
Though not necessarily Halloween specific, this “tuxedo” suit for dogs also came recommended as a costume. Eight reviewers said it was “absolutely fabulous,” with the short sleeves being singled out for making it more adaptable for different breeds (fans included everything from a Yorkshire terrier to a Dalmatian). One reviewer, who used it to dress their dog up as James Bond, said the stretchy material was easy to hand wash, and even ironed well provided the iron was not too hot. Another happy customer said their small dog, who wore padded coats in winter, barely registered the difference, and happily wore this outfit to the park. Seven customers also bought these for weddings — including a woman who wanted her two Boston terriers to walk down the aisle with her.
Best lion mane
This furry hood is a simpler outfit than most, but came highly recommended by customers. Sixteen reviewers said it was a great alternative to a full costume, which many dogs find uncomfortable or irritating. The outfit was most popular with larger dogs (there were 11 reviews by Labrador owners, although boxers and cockapoos also seemed to enjoy it), and the hidden drawstrings mean this can be adjusted for smaller breeds — 17 reviewers were impressed at how well it fitted their dogs.
The Strategist UK is designed to surface the most useful, expert recommendations for things to buy across the vast e-commerce landscape. Read about who we are and what we do here. Our editors update links when possible, but note that deals can expire and all prices are subject to change.