Here at the Strategist UK, we like to think of ourselves as crazy (in the good way) about the stuff we buy, but as much as we’d like to, we can’t try everything. Which is why we have People’s Choice, in which we find the best-reviewed products and single out the most convincing ones. (You can learn more about our rating system and how we pick each item here.)
And while we’ve written about lots of ways to get a good night’s sleep on our US website — including the best mattress toppers, the best pillows, and the best sheets — here, we’ve rounded up the best mattresses, as praised by the most enthusiastic reviewers on Amazon.
Note: To even the playing field a bit, we focused on UK double-bed mattresses (135 cm x 190 cm), but all of these mattresses are available in other sizes as well. According to reviewers, every mattress on this list comes rolled and tightly packed for delivery.
This mattress, from the UK-based company Starlight Beds, is the best-rated double bed mattress on Amazon and the most affordable mattress on this list. Score. Hundreds praise the mattress’s good value, with 30 customers saying it’s great for bargain-hunters and folks on a budget. The mattress uses an open-coil-spring design and is topped with a layer of memory foam, which provides medium-soft support (20 reviewers say that the softness makes it particularly popular with kids). It’s important to note that not all customers were impressed by the mattress — critical reviewers do say that you get what you pay for. However, most reviews are very positive, and dozens of people say that they were amazed or surprised by the quality for the price. According to one reviewer, they would have happily paid double.
Best mattress for couples
This Inofia mattress has 500 five-star reviews, from buyers who describe the mattress as firm, supportive, and comfortable. More than a hundred positive reviews are written by couples, or else specifically mention that the mattress was a hit with the reviewer’s partner. The mattress uses a combination of foam and individual pocket springs, which provide firmer support than open coil springs, and reduce the amount of movement and ‘roll together’ that can be felt if you’re sharing the bed with someone else. As one customer says, the mattress has great individual support with no sagging, rolling into the middle, or waking each other up. Although this mattress is more costly than the Starlight mattress, over 100 reviewers call it affordable or great value for money. Several mention that it outperforms the £1000-plus mattresses they have had in the past. Like the Starlight mattress, the Inofia comes vacuum-packed for easy delivery. In addition, the company provides a 100-night test period, during which they guarantee a full refund if you wish to return the product.
Best mattress for back pain
In the reviews for this DOSLEEPS mattress, 70 customers say that they experience aches and pain in their back or joints. Among those customers, 60 give this mattress a five-star review. The company claims that the mattress’s orthopaedic benefits come from its high-quality, individually pocketed springs combined with a thick top-layer of memory foam. According to DOSLEEPS, the combination of these materials allow the mattress to ‘intelligently adjust’ to a sleeper’s body, enabling their hips and shoulders to sink comfortably into the mattress while providing ample support for the neck and head. Consequently, two-thirds of all reviewers describe the mattress as comfy, including ten people who call it the most comfortable mattress they have ever owned. Dozens of reviewers — who identify as back, side, and stomach sleepers — also say the mattress offers good support and resistance without feeling too hard. The outer fabric is made of sustainable Tencel lyocell fibers and, similar to the Inofia, the mattress comes with a money-back guarantee for 90 days.
Best medium-soft mattress
This mattress has a similar pocket spring and foam structure to the DOSLEEPS and Inofia mattresses, but offers a slightly softer surface for buyers who prefer a medium-soft feel. Customers give the mattress top marks for comfort, and more than 40 attest that it is just the right balance of softness and supportiveness, whether you’re sitting or lying down. Two customers report that, according to their family members, it’s like sleeping on clouds. Another writes that they can’t tell if the mattress is technically firm or soft — all they know is that it’s ‘comfy as hell’. This mattress also comes with a 100-night trial period, but according to reviewers, this is only if you order it direct from the manufacturer.